LY Traders · working draft — blog 33 · source: Jared Tendler trading psychology survey (1,273 respondents, Nov 2021; re-run 2026)
In late 2021, trading psychology coach Jared Tendler ran one of the largest surveys ever conducted on how traders experience emotion: 1,273 respondents across eight trading communities. The numbers were stark. 96% believed psychology plays an important role in trading. 91% could see when emotions were affecting their decisions. Only 34% had a concrete strategy for managing those emotions.
A 57-point gap between seeing the problem and having a mechanism for it.
Five years later, Tendler ran the survey again. The number with a concrete strategy rose to 45%. After half a decade of books, podcasts, courses, and an entire content industry dedicated to trading psychology, the gap closed by eleven points.
That slow rate of change is the finding. Not the gap itself — how stubborn it is.
Fear was the most-reported emotion (43%), followed by lack of confidence (22%), overconfidence (15%), and greed (13%). Almost everyone surveyed could name which one visits them. Naming is genuinely the first step — and it is also where most traders stop, because naming produces the sensation of insight without changing a single decision.
The survey's own conclusion put it precisely: a massive disconnect between beliefs and mental skill. Traders either fail to recognise the inconsistency, or they do not know how to address it. The second group is the larger one, and the five-year re-run suggests the content economy is not closing it. Another book consumed is another piece of awareness added to a mind that already knew.
The 45% who now report a concrete strategy deserve scrutiny too. A plan to "stay calm and cut size when tilted" is a wish with a schedule. It executes through the same instrument that is compromised in the moment — the trader under emotion. A strategy is concrete only when the decisions inside it are made somewhere other than the emotional state itself: position size set before the session, invalidation level written down, maximum daily action defined, and every one of those applied identically whether the morning is calm or chaotic.
This is the same distinction that separates traders who know their rules from traders who follow them. Knowing the rules is not the same as applying them consistently. The survey measures exactly that gap and shows it is durable across five years and 1,273 people.
The mechanics are unforgiving. The moment a trader most needs discipline is the moment emotion has the most influence over the instrument that would supply it. Willpower is not absent during drawdowns because traders are weak; it is absent because that is when the fear response is doing its biological job. A mitigation strategy that depends on the compromised resource fails at the exact moment it is needed.
Which explains why awareness campaigns plateau. Information upgrades beliefs. It does not upgrade the execution path between belief and action during a losing session.
The fix is structural, not motivational. Move every rule that can be decided in advance out of the live moment: sizing computed before entry, stop and invalidation levels attached to the position, session windows fixed, daily limits encoded. What remains for the human is the part machines cannot hold — choosing the strategy, setting its parameters, and reviewing its results honestly.
This is the role automation genuinely plays in a trading operation. Not forecasting, not signal generation — enforcement. A Trading Bot (EA) applies the configured rules at 2 a.m. with the same indifference it had at 10 a.m., which is precisely the property the survey shows most traders lack and cannot train quickly. The plan remains the trader's. The execution stops negotiating.
The survey's 57-point gap is evidence for a specific claim: five years of knowing changed almost nothing, because knowing was never the missing layer. The missing layer is a mechanism that holds the rules when their owner cannot.
Discipline is the mechanism.
Survey data: Jared Tendler, trading psychology survey of 1,273 traders across eight trading communities, November 2021, re-run 2026. Figures cited with attribution to jaredtendler.com — thanks to Jared for sharing the data publicly.